Founder & Lead College Admissions Consultant
Admissions by Design

Strategic College Planning

Thoughtful Planning. Insider Admissions Insight.
Two Decades of Experience.

& Admissions Counseling

KARA MCMAHON

Why Families Choose
Admissions by Design

Nearly 20 years of college admissions counseling experience
Former Villanova University admissions liaison
Personalized application strategy, not generic advice
A proven framework helping students stand out at top universities

A Tailored Approach to College Planning.

A Tailored Approach to College Planning.

• Nearly 20 years of college admissions counseling experience
• Former Villanova University admissions liaison
• Personalized application strategy — not generic advice
• A proven framework helping students stand out at selective universities

A Thoughtful, Structured Approach to College Planning

Expertise & Experience

20 years of college admissions counseling experience

10 years as a high school college counselor

• Former Director of Counseling

Member of Independent Educational Consultants Association (IECA)

Insider Admissions Experience

• Former Alumni Admissions Liaison, Villanova University

Interviewed applicants for admission and scholarships

Participated in admissions committee discussions

Direct knowledge of how applications are evaluated behind closed doors

“With nearly two decades in secondary education and college admissions counseling, I guide students and families through one of the most significant transitions of their academic journey.

My background includes leadership in high school counseling, firsthand experience reviewing applications at the university level, and extensive work supporting diverse academic profiles.

Each engagement is built on strategic planning, individualized positioning, and long-term clarity.”

About Me

KARA MCMAHON

Kara McMahon is a college admissions counselor with almost two decades of experience helping students and families navigate the increasingly complex college application process with clarity and confidence.

She earned her undergraduate degree from Villanova University, a Master’s in Counseling from Fordham University, and a degree in Educational Administration from Hofstra University. Kara spent 10 years as a college counselor at a public high school on Long Island, supporting students with diverse academic profiles and postsecondary goals. She later served as the Director of Counseling at an all-girls Catholic high school in Milwaukee, where she oversaw the college planning process and guided students throughout all four years of high school.

Earlier in her career, Kara worked for approximately three years as an alumni admissions liaison at Villanova University. In that role, she interviewed applicants for admission and scholarships and participated in admissions committee discussions, giving her firsthand insight into how applications are reviewed, discussed, and evaluated behind closed doors.

Kara founded Admissions by Design with a singular focus: helping students present a cohesive, compelling story rather than a collection of disconnected accomplishments. Her strength lies in curating each student’s academic choices, activities, essays, and experiences into an intentional narrative that clearly communicates who the student is, what matters to them, and where they are headed. Known for her calm, supportive style and highly organized systems, Kara works with students nationwide to create customized roadmaps, guide long-term planning, and ensure every piece of the application works together as one cohesive story.

Services

Strategic Admissions Support,
Built for Every Stage

Every student’s journey is different. Whether building early foundations or preparing to submit applications, my work is rooted in long-term strategy, thoughtful positioning, and cohesive storytelling.

Families may begin as early as ninth grade or join during the critical junior year. Each pathway is designed with intention and clarity.

Ways to Work Together

  • College admissions consultant meeting with a student to discuss college planning and application strategy.

    Foundations Package

    Grades 9–10 | Long-Term Strategic Planning

  • College admissions counseling session with a student reviewing college planning materials.

    The Blueprint Package

    Grades 11–12 | Strategic Positioning & Application Execution

  • College admissions consultant working on application strategy and college planning on a laptop.

    Applications 101

    Six-Month Guided Online Workshop

Not sure which path is the best fit for your student?

Schedule a consultation to clarify goals, timing, and long-term positioning.

Who This Is For

• Families who value long-term planning

• Students targeting selective or competitive programs

• Those who prefer structured, organized guidance

• Students ready to take ownership of their growth


What is Admission by Design for?

How My Advising Works

My approach is rooted in long-term strategy, thoughtful positioning, and cohesive storytelling. Rather than reacting in senior year, we build intentionally — aligning academics, leadership, activities, and narrative so that each application reflects both depth and direction.
Every engagement is structured, personalized, and focused on clarity — ensuring students move through the process with confidence and purpose.

Where Students Have Been Admitted

Universities where Kara’s students have been admitted include:

Follow us on Instagram